李子柒被寫入語文期末試卷,家長和網友吵翻了!出題人卻回應說……

2020-07-06     恆星英語學習網

原標題:李子柒被寫入語文期末試卷,家長和網友吵翻了!出題人卻回應說……

近日,#李子柒被寫入小學語文考卷#衝上熱搜。

事情起因是浙江寧波海曙區的一份小學六年級期末語文考卷。有家長在論壇上發帖稱,試卷的作文題給出了「網紅」李子柒的故事,旨在展示中國傳統田園文化,最後卻介紹了李子柒的粉絲數,這讓其無法接受,這位家長甚至直指「出卷老師知識淺薄」。

In the final exam of Grade 6 Chinese language course this semester, a school in Ningbo, Zhejiang province, included popular Chinese food blogger Li Ziqi as a good example for students to emulate. One parent shared the photo of the exam paper and expressed the concern that it might mislead kids by teaching them the wrong values.

The photo of the exam paper shows Li was selected for promoting an idyllic traditional Chinese lifestyle and for spreading traditional Chinese culture to the world. Li has a huge global following for her videos which show her preparing meals that she shares with her grandmother.

經核實,這道題並不是作文題,而是閱讀理解題。其中提供了袁隆平、李子柒和中國詩詞大會第三季冠軍外賣小哥雷海為的三段材料,讓學生任選一人為「心目中的風雲人物」寫推薦表。

It is also worth noting that Li was one of three examples that the children were presented with. The other two were Yuan Longping, a renowned Chinese agronomist and Lei Haiwei, a deliveryman and the winner of the third season of China Central Television's poetry competition show. The children were asked to select one and give their reasons why they chose that one.

「會不會帶偏孩子的價值觀呢?」

該家長的質疑

引髮網友們激烈爭論

他列出了

「李子柒能否代表中國傳統田園生活?」

等七大理由

但這位家長同時也承認,自己事先並不清楚李子柒「是何許人也,只是偶有耳聞」。

對於他的顧慮,有不少人表示贊同

也有很多人支持這種出題方式

Some Chinese netizens supported the parent saying "putting Li's fan numbers on the exam paper is like advertising for a public figure, which is not acceptable."

Other Chinese netizens said Li is an inspirational celebrity who promotes Chinese culture to the world, and deserves to be known by students.

"Such a question allows students to keep pace with the times and broadens their knowledge beyond textbooks," a Chinese netizen wrote on Weibo.

面對網友的爭議,《錢江晚報》小時新聞記者近日採訪了這套試卷的出題者、寧波市海曙區教育局教研室楊柳老師。

楊老師告訴記者,感謝家長對語文教育的關注,但發帖家長弄錯一個基本事實,這是閱讀題,不是作文題,試卷的作文是「寫給最美逆行者的一封信」。

楊老師講述了自己作為出題者的考量:「這三段並列的人物材料,主要考查學生的快速閱讀和理解概括信息的能力。」 她表示,三個人物都是為理想不畏艱難、克服重重困難圓夢的典型,對孩子來說,是正能量的鼓勵。出題時考慮到李子柒這個人物,各大媒體都做過正面報道。李子柒對傳統文化的貢獻以及認真做事的精神,確實值得大家學習。

Yang Liu, the teacher who designed the test, told the reporter of Qianjiang Evening News that the question was in a reading section of the exam and asked students about three public luminaries including the motivational story of Yuan Longping, a globally renowned agronomist known for developing the first hybrid rice strains.

"The three characters are all typical figures who have overcome many difficulties. They are positive role models for children," said Yang.

確實,李子柒此前已得到多家媒體的較高評價。

白岩松在提到「李子柒現象」時也曾說到:「過高評價或過低質疑都不一定對,微笑著鼓掌是最好的。」並表示像她這樣的網紅太少了。

而在一個多月前李子柒與袁隆平、申紀蘭等6人,受聘為首批「中國農民豐收節推廣大使」。

多年從事小學語文教育的寧波市海曙區王悅微老師表示,語文是一門包羅萬象的學科,新聞熱點、社會問題成為考題的一部分很正常,也很必要。

《錢江晚報》小時新聞記者也採訪了寧波海曙區教育局黨委書記、局長朱子凡。他表示,近年來中考和高考都越來越關注社會現實問題。海曙區這一次小學六年級語文期末考試卷增加課本以外的社會知識,是一種嘗試,也是為了和中、高考接軌。「不要過度拘泥於網紅這一話題。」朱子凡說,問題的本質在於,「我們的考試,除了圍繞課本知識,還應該有更多的社會和生活的內容。」

The local education administration's director general, Zhu Zifan said the exam's format was similar to the middle and high school entrance exams which contain readings that focus more on some social issues, the Qianjiang Evening News reported.

上述家長的擔憂、質疑

或許也是緣於不了解甚至誤解

對於這件事,

你怎麼看?

文章來源: https://twgreatdaily.com/zh-cn/ow6QJnMBnkjnB-0zk-dj.html